Carriage House One-Bedroom Hidden Behind Chelsea’s “Muffin House” Asks $875K

Carriage House One-Bedroom Hidden Behind Chelsea’s “Muffin House” Asks $875K


A living area with a bookshelf, two framed windows, hardwood floors, several chairs, and a rug.Photos: Joel Pitra, DDReps/Courtesy of Compass

The apartment has four windows overlooking the common courtyard.

Price: $875,000
Location: Chelsea, Manhattan

To access this one-bedroom, located on the second floor of a four-story 1850 carriage house, one first has to navigate through the foyer of a brick townhouse and a stone-paved courtyard garden. That front townhouse, a co-op building that shares the same address, was originally constructed as a foundry and was more recently dubbed the “Muffin House” when, in 2006, a couple living in a ground-floor apartment there uncovered a huge brick oven behind their basement wall that was believed to have been used by Samuel Bath Thomas, founder of Thomas’ English Muffins. Thomas, as it turns out, bought the place in the early 20th century to expand his bakery just around the corner. 337 West 20th Street sits among a row of mostly brick townhouses between 8th and 9th Avenues and is a five-minute walk to the C/E trains at 23rd Street.

Specs: 1 bed, 1 bath, approx. 500 square feet

3M, one of a dozen mostly one-bedroom apartments across the two buildings, is a single-floor unit with four south-facing windows overlooking the courtyard garden, which has a dedicated seating area surrounded by hydrangeas. An updated kitchen comes with a small window of its own and includes open shelving, a dishwasher, and wine fridge. From the main living area, you’ll pass a tiny storage-equipped hallway to get to the square-shaped bedroom, behind which there is a walk-in closet with built-in dresser drawers. The bathroom, too, has a window, a frameless glass shower, white tile, and a washer-dryer. Base moldings and hardwood floors run throughout, and maintenance charges amount to $1,140 per month.

The back of a four-story carriage house with brick tiles, a planter fountain, a barbecue grill, and several plants.
The common courtyard garden, which sits atop the rediscovered brick oven used by Thomas, features a planter fountain, seating area, and hydrangeas aplenty.
A hallway with hardwood floors, base moldings, and white cabinets.
There are hardwood floors and base moldings throughout the unit.
A living area with two windows, base moldings, hardwood floors, a round wooden table with two chairs, and a beige couch.
The living-room windows overlook the courtyard.
A kitchen with white cabinetry, an island, and stainless steel appliances.
The open kitchen has open shelving, stainless-steel appliances, and a wine fridge.
An open kitchen with a window, an island, and white cabinetry.
There’s a small window in the kitchen.
A bedroom with a large bed, two framed windows, a colorful rug, grey walls, and base moldings.
The spacious bedroom comes with two windows also overlooking the garden.

Curbed NY


Love where you live

Be Heard at Go Home NY

Be heard! Leave your apartment, condo, and coop building reviews at Go Home NY! Know a building's managers are awful? Have the inside line on a perfect building? Anything in between? Express your voice and be heard. Leave a review at Go Home NY.

Written by 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *